Access
Open Access
Date Range
1973-1977
Description
This collection includes a letter to Bertram Schefold discussing travel expenses and an honorarium, a postcard from Ei Nagakudo(?) thanking Shaikh for his political economy classes and a recommendation for an internship at the UN (3/18/98), a card from Mara Kaufman thanking Shaikh for allowing her to sit in on one of his political economy courses, a flyer for New School featuring Shaikh, a watercolor painting, a letter from Diana, a receipt for a $10 submission fee for a paper titled “The So-Called ‘Transformation Problem’: Marx Vindicated”, a flyer for Karl Marx's birdthday with lyrics for “The International”, a flier advertising a Karl Marx pub crawl (5/1/99), an excerpt from Karl Liebknecht’s book Karl Marx Biographical Memoirs discussing Liebknecht’s friendship with Marx and his son being buried at Whitefield Memorial Chapel, a map of the Karl Marx pub crawl route, a letter to a friend discussing differences between the post-Keynesian tradition and fundamentalists, a letter from Edward J. Nell discussing Shaikh’s paper, the Simon-Levy paper, Walters, and Bronfenbrenner’s book Income Distribution Theory (3/1/72), a letter from Scott Ross(?) requesting a copy of the humbug production function paper and mentioning Joan Robinson (9/13/72), a letter from Scott discussing Cobb-Douglass functions, econometrics, and a trip to the US (11/14/72), a letter from B. C. Chakrabarti requesting reprints of Shaikh’s articles (3/16/73), a letter from Ian Steedman requesting a copy of Shaikh’s paper “Laws of Production and Laws of Algebra” (3/14/73), a letter from Leeroy Murray, a final year student at the Middlesex Polytechnic, Enfield, requesting a copy of Shaikh’s article on the “Humbug Production Function” (3/30/73), a letter from Ian Steedman thanking Shaikh for his paper and mentioning Henryk Grossman (4/12/73), a letter from Harcourt thanking Shaikh for his letter and paper and discussing the Humbug paper, the Quarterly Journal of Economics, and the Review of Radical Political Economics (6/30/73), a letter from LeRoy Murray thanking Shaikh for forwarding his article and discussing his final year exams and B.A. Social Science degree (10/3/73), a letter from Harcourt discussing Shaikh’s comments on Solow and the Review of Economics and Statistics, Borts and the American Economic Review, and getting Shaikh’s dissertation into publishable shape (8/13/74), a letter from Harcourt discussing Shaikh’s previous version of a paper and mentioning Tom Cooley, Ros. Seneca, and the International Economic Association Conference in Spain (2/11/75), a letter from Harcourt thanking Shaikh for sending the rewrite (2/14/75), a letter from Harcourt discussing the Australian Economic Papers accepting Shaikh’s mathematical paper and Houthakker and Solow’s treatment of Shaikh (3/5/75), a check to the NY DMV $65 (9/25/07), a parking violation notice (9/8/07), a letter from Joan Robinson discussing Shaikh’s paper and publication possibilities (7/5/72), a letter to Robinson discussing the paper’s submission to The Review of Economics and Statistics and Franklin Fisher’s letter (10/13/72), a letter from Robinson discussing Fisher’s faith and "micro system" (10/25/72), a letter from Robinson discussing Shaikh’s article on the transformation problem and the Economic Journal (5/23/73), a letter to Robinson discussing the American Economic Review’s rejection of his paper and Morishima’s book Marx’s Economics (8/6/73), a letter from Robinson discussing Moroshima and Schefold (8/14/73), letter from D. G. Champernowne, the editor of The Economic Journal, rejecting Shaikh’s article "The So-Called Transformation Problem: Marx Vindicated" (10/5/73), letter from Joan Robinson discussing a possible trip by Shaikh to Cambridge and his work on a math book (3/15/74), letter from Joan Robinson discussing Shaikh’s paper on the so-called transformation problem (2/9/75), letter to Robinson discussing his two articles, one on the theory of trade and its relation to Marx's law of value, and the other on an unsuccessful grant proposal to the National Science Foundation (7/14/76), letter from Joan Robinson discussing conversations with Okishio and his views on the falling rate of profit (8/12/76), letter to Robinson discussing his paper on the falling rate of profit, his trade paper, and his paper on the labor theory of value (3/14/77), letter from Robinson discussing Ricardo, Okishio's article, the labor theory of value, and Shaikh’s upcoming visit to Cambridge (3/24/77), and a letter from Robinson discussing Shaikh’s paper on trade, Ricardo's theory of profits, Marxian theory, and the labor theory of value.
Recommended Citation
s, Anwar PhD, "Joan Robinson et al. 2" (2025). Archives of Anwar Shaikh. 206.
https://digitalcommons.bard.edu/as_archive/206
Comments
A large number of these letters were also filed in the first collection of correspondence with Joan Robinson.
The inclusion of the DMV parking citation from 2007 is clearly an error.