Access
Open Access
Date Range
1972-1975
Description
This includes a letter to George H. Borts containing Shaikh's paper "The So-Called Transformation Problem" (5/11/73), a letter from Edward J. Nell with comments on Shaikh's paper (3/1/72), a letter to Review of Economics and Statistics with Shaikh's paper (5/30/72), a letter of receipt from Review of Economics and Statistics (6/1/72), a reply by Shaikh containing additional copies (6/5/72), a letter from a person at University of Bristol requesting a copy of the paper (11/13/72), a letter to Review of Economics and Statistics requesting a status update regarding his paper “Laws of Algebra and Laws of Production” (10/11/72), a letter to Review of Economics and Statistics containing revisions (10/30/72), a letter from Franklin M. Fisher with critical comments (11/8/72), a letter from a Professor of Economics at the University of Bristol with a comment (11/14/72), a letter to Review of Economics and Statistics requesting status update (2/22/73), a reply from Hendrik S. Houthakker that the paper will be published (3/8/73), a letter from Ian Steedman requesting a copy of the paper (3/14), a letter from a faculty member of the University of Calcutta requesting a copy (3/16/73), a letter from a student at Middlesex Polytechnic requesting a copy (3/30/73), a letter from Steedman thanking Shaikh and requesting a copy for his student (4/11/73), a letter from someone at University of Cambridge requesting a copy (6/30/73), a letter from Leoroy thanking Shaikh for the copy and enclosing another paper (10/3/73), a letter from Joan Robinson commenting that she felt he should have been given the opportunity to respond to Professor Solow who critiqued his paper (6/21/74), a letter from Luigi Passinetti commenting on the paper (6/7/74), a letter to Houthakker complaining that Shaikh was not able to reply to Solow's comment (6/28/74), a reply noting that Professor Shaikh’s paper was basically a critique of Professor Solow and that the case was now closed (7/1/74), a letter by G. C. Harcourt accepting Shaikh's paper in AEP and commenting on Houthakker's response (3/5/75), Harcourt expressing satisfaction at Shaikh's new paper (2/14/75), from Harcourt regarding publishing Shaik's paper in AEP (2/11/75), and Harcourt regarding publishing Shaikh's papers (8/13/74).
Recommended Citation
Shaikh, Anwar PhD, "Humbug Paper" (2025). Archives of Anwar Shaikh. 161.
https://digitalcommons.bard.edu/as_archive/161